Which banner should i choose?

[Prilixy]

so i made two similiar banners which one is the best?

 

[TwilightPrinze]

Well if you leave out the black square behind the name and make the Text a bit lighter so it is easier to read then were getting somewhere

 

[TheGaminCentral]

For me the text is not that readable...one thing keep in mind no matter what u do make the text readable and the particles that u have used are not blending in so it looks not good
The first one the text is visible so that's good but overall I don't like the background that much

 

[Pyro TurtleGaming]

First of all, good job on this. everything seems to pull your eyes to the middle. Bravo.
And i think the first one is better because the glow makes the other ones hard to read, however if you modified the second design by making the top and bottom of the circle there but cut out the middle that would work.