What's the BEST Pokemon Game ever?

[Anthony Deal]

There has always been a debate about what generation of Pokemon created the best game. I'm here to ask you all, whats your opinion?
Generation 1 with Red/Blue/Yellow
Generation 2 with Gold/Silver/Crystal
Generation 3 with Ruby/Sapphire/Emerald
Generation 4 with Diamond/Pearl/Platinum
Generation 5 with Black/White
Generation 6 with X/Y

I excluded remakes like FireRed/Leaf Green, HeartGold/SoulSilver and so on.

What's your opinion and why?

 

[Kratos Aurion]

I found the story in Black and White to be my personal favorite.

X/Y are my least favorites.

Story/Overall:
5/2/3/1/4/6

Gameplay:
5/4/3/6/2/1

 

[Mariksrevenge]

I enjoyed Gold and Silver a lot just because it was such a large map with so much nostalgia when it came to going back to Kanto. I also really enjoyed the original RSE and also D/P
Least favourite has to be X/Y. Not that its a bad game (I enjoy them all for the most part, I play pokemon) but it was just very easy and too many companions. It was the first 3DS game but they really refined the ideas in ORAS.

 

[Anime Always]

Pokemon emerald as it is the only pokemon game I ever played lol...

 

[Anthony Deal]

I found the story in Black and White to be my personal favorite.

X/Y are my least favorites.

Story/Overall:
5/2/3/1/4/6

Gameplay:
5/4/3/6/2/1

Thank you so much for your input. Honestly I own both Black and White but I've never played through them. However when I get my capture card in I will hopefully being doing an LP of them.[DOUBLEPOST=1453340949][/DOUBLEPOST]

Pokemon emerald as it is the only pokemon game I ever played lol...

Emerald is a very great game. I'm currently doing an LP of that on my channel, if ya get the chance to check it out lol[DOUBLEPOST=1453341050][/DOUBLEPOST]

I enjoyed Gold and Silver a lot just because it was such a large map with so much nostalgia when it came to going back to Kanto. I also really enjoyed the original RSE and also D/P
Least favourite has to be X/Y. Not that its a bad game (I enjoy them all for the most part, I play pokemon) but it was just very easy and too many companions. It was the first 3DS game but they really refined the ideas in ORAS.

I agree with you about X/Y. It did seem a little too easy. Especially when they brought in WonderTrading.

 

[TwilightPrinze]

Hmm honestly i like most of them but i think the best was Yellow as this was coming close to the series. Looking back at it now compared to the new ones it still is fun. The oldskool colors, the vibe and the fact pikachu just doesn't like you up to a certain point