Elgato works so well for me I would highly recommend it. If you want to see the quality check out my channel the infamous or phantasy star videos are good examples www.youtube.com/dakendude
I currently have the HDPVR but only the first version quite like the PVR as it has a lot of features built into the software, but would like to get the elgato HD60 supposed to be really good, and really good quality.