YouTube is this legal

[RoboPlayground]

just come by this channel its complication of other videos and all this videos are monetized is this legit or can u get a strike for this if it is legit how what grounds can i make a channel like this

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCqoOcEKFZnV1zQ4khXzG6kg/videos

 

[LW]

If you're using someone else's stuff without adding your own content to it you can get problems.

 

[RoboPlayground]

this channel seem to get no problems how if u know

 

[RockieGO]

see what my next channel will be...

lets see what i can rip off,and change some music and film speed to make it my own and be RICH!!

I see this crap all the time on YouTube, so long its family safe. YT doesn't care much

 

[RoboPlayground]

i get that its funny and not much will report it but can anyone tell me if this is this copyright free what he is doing here if no why does he get to upload regularly monetize and nothing happens and has a entire channel on these type of videos[DOUBLEPOST=1517277195][/DOUBLEPOST]i dont want a answer on anyone opinion on the channel just wana know if there is anything wrong with it copyright wise im thinking of making a channel like this

 

[RockieGO]

try this.
https://www.videomaker.com/article/c2/14261-whats-legal-youtube-fair-use-vs-copyright-laws

There are two areas. FAIR USE and COPYRIGHT.

some being old and seen on TV, could fall into fair use. and with not one noticing it and being a short videos, could fall into that.
its a FINE line between those two..
-
https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2797449?hl=en
https://www.youtube.com/intl/en-GB/yt/about/copyright/fair-use/
www.youtube.com/yt/copyright

 

[LW]

This channel shoots miles beyond fair use, how would you know it isn't striked or claimed though? You can mess with copyright if you want to but as soon as you're caught you're gone.

 

[RoboPlayground]

im still not getting a clear answer after reading the link and the comments here can i make a channel like this or what

 

[LW]

im still not getting a clear answer after reading the link and the comments here can i make a channel like this or what

If you want to we can't stop you. But you might get strikes or claims and you definitely will lose the chance to join any MCN.

 

[RoboPlayground]

why would i get strikes and claims if this channel is not is this guy lucky or does what he is doing fall under some kind of fair use ?

 

[LW]

why would i get strikes and claims if this channel is not is this guy lucky or does what he is doing fall under some kind of fair use ?

1) you can't tell who is monetizing a video
2) you can't tell whether a channel is in amazing standing or one strike away from being terminated
3) just because he isn't being caught doesn't mean he can't get caught. If a rights owner wants to take down a video they can.

Also where's the fun in reuploading videos others have made? Why not grow your audience with your own personality instead of throwing other people's videos on the wall hoping they stick? If you want to make money, get a job and earn it morally.

Your question is pretty much looking at someone who robbed a jewelry store but wasn't yet caught by police asking why you can't rob a store yourself.

 

[RoboPlayground]

im shocked that u said 1) you can't tell who is monetizing a video .............................
and from what i get u are saying what he is doing is wrong just not caught yet and thanks fincally not so much of a beat around the bush answer but her its a good answer

 

[LW]

im shocked that u said 1) you can't tell who is monetizing a video .............................

You know it for your own channel but there's no way to see it for another channel, sorry if that was a bit unclear

 

[RoboPlayground]

uhh im pretty sure i can tell if a video is monetized

 

[LW]

uhh im pretty sure i can tell if a video is monetized

You can't know whether or not the ad revenue goes to the creator or a claimant.

 

[RoboPlayground]

yea i can pretty sure if someone profit is keep being claimed and he is getting no money he wont continuously uploading that same type of content its only common sense hope u are not a official here if so u should actually be fired

 

[LW]

hope u are not a official here if so u should actually be fired

what even

 

[Koala_Steamed]

At first I thought this was just plain copyright, but I looks like it falls under fair use. They are splicing videos together for comedic effect and adding sound/music over it as well. So they are essentially creating "new content". That being said I'd hate to be their lawyer...

Just be very careful if you want to make a channel like this, there is a difference between just finding your favorite videos and reuploading together vs what this channel is doing.

yea i can pretty sure if someone profit is keep being claimed and he is getting no money he wont continuously uploading that same type of content its only common sense hope u are not a official here if so u should actually be fired

It's possible for monetization to be claimed by multiple parties. So if a music clip goes for 5% of the video they can claim 5% of the monetization. The own of this channel may only be getting a % of the overall demonetization.

 

[RoboPlayground]

ah i see thank you for reply

 

[RockieGO]

Yeah........

try this.
https://www.videomaker.com/article/c2/14261-whats-legal-youtube-fair-use-vs-copyright-laws

There are two areas. FAIR USE and COPYRIGHT.

some being old and seen on TV, could fall into fair use. and with not one noticing it and being a short videos, could fall into that.
its a FINE line between those two..
-
https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2797449?hl=en
https://www.youtube.com/intl/en-GB/yt/about/copyright/fair-use/
www.youtube.com/yt/copyright