Opinion Content ID Tool

Hyderpony

Community Team
Community Team!
Verified Freedom! Partner
Freedom! Member
May 19, 2017
397
113
41
London
YouTube
GallopCrush1983
I wish there be a time that everyone can use a content-id tool on YouTube/Freedom without needing 100k subs or a select people on YouTube/Freedom.
 

zeke morgan

Mythic User
Freedom! Member
Dec 8, 2015
3,810
1,638
YouTube
That would be nice but im sure they have to balance the fairness of people protecting their content with people using it for malicious reasons
 

LW

Community Manager
Administrator
Moderator
Freedom! Member
Apr 2, 2016
3,045
1,251
21
Vienna, Austria
twitter.com
YouTube
lw_001
It seems that any channels that under 100k subs are 2nd class by YouTube.
While it seems like this there's a sad fact that those channels are almost guaranteed not to be spam channels who create actual content. 100k is a good barrier for them to set for access to such a powerful feature. Content ID takes a lot of computing time and power. By giving a single channel access to it they have to add and index hundreds of thousands of videos to the database every second of every uploaded video is compared to. The tool was originally just designed for music until movie companies started to complain. It has a ton of false positives (See the support forum here or your email inbox to get a taste). If they give everyone access to it there will be even more false claims "solidified" by Content ID matches. Also without access to numbers I don't think many videos of channels under that number are even reuploaded. It never hurts though to look over your most popular videos and to search for similar videos to find potential reuploads and to take them down using the old DMCA form. Freedom! might be able to use it's CID access to do this for larger partners (by setting the thing to "track" for those assets, not sure if that's possible for only some things though) but I don't think it's what YouTube wants the thing to be used for... But who knows, maybe one day computing power will grow on trees and they can open up access to it but at the moment that's highly unlikely